Cubs Vs. Brewers

Everyone is obviously, picking the Cubs to win this division, but I thought I would compare our players with the cubs players at each position. I really don't know how to adequately compare them, so I'm going to use an arbitrary 1-5 number system. Maybe I'll get crazy and throw some decimals in there. Consider this an overall grade, with an obvious bias towards offense. My numbers equate to 2.5=average  3+=very good  4+=All Star  5=Hall of Fame

Catcher:
Kendall 2.2
Soto      2.6

1st Base:
Fielder  4.5
Lee        3.7

2nd Base:
Weeks   2.9
Derosa  2.5

3rd Base:
Hall         2.8
Ramirez 4.2

Shortstop:
Hardy      3.2
Theriot    2.8

Left Field:
Braun      4.4
Soriano   4.4

Centerfield:
Cameron/Gwynn   3.4
Pie/Johnson            2.8

Right Field:
Hart                 3.9
Fukudome      2.8

Ace:
Sheets              3.6
Zambrano        4.2

#2 Pitcher:
Gallardo         3.9
Lilly                 3.7

#3 Pitcher:
Suppan           2.7
Hill                  3.6

#4 Pitcher:
Bush                2.4
Dempster       2.9

#5 Pitcher:
Villy/Manny    3.4
Marquis           2.8

Closer:
Gagne               3.8
Wood                3.6

Setup:
Turnbow           3.3
Marmol             4.2

Riske                  3.6
Howry                3.9

Mota                  2.9
Lieber                2.5

Shouse               3.1
Hart                    2.6

Torres                3.5
Wuertz               3.7

That's what I've come up with. I really tried to be as objective as possible, but my Cubs hatred runs pretty deep.

Here are the final tallies:
Brewers:  63.5
Cubs:       63.5

I really did not mean for the numbers to be exact, but I guess that shows what kind of season we have in front of us.

Feel free to agree or rip apart any of these rankings.