Recapping the Draft [Updated]
First, though, updates on signing statuses:
- Eric Arnett is expected to sign shortly for about $1.2M.
- We were worried about whether Kentrail Davis would sign, because of his extra leverage as a sophomore and the fact that he's a Scott Boras client, but he sounds like he's ready to turn pro.
- From Adam McCalvy:
the list of players already under contract includes third-round pick Josh Prince, a shortstop from Tulane; sixth-rounder Hiram Burgos, a right-hander from Bethune-Cookman; ninth-rounder Jonathan Pokorny, a left-hander from Kent State; and 10th-rounder Tyler Roberts, a high school catcher from Georgia. In addition, the team had come to terms with second-rounder Max Walla, a high school outfielder from Albuquerque who wowed club officials in a Miller Park workout last weekend, and was close to agreeing with another second-round pick, high school catcher Cameron Garfield.
- Prep righty Brooks Hall, BA's #134 overall prospect, has an 88-92 MPH fastball that touches 94 and a hard slider that has plus potential. Because of his bonus demands and a strong commitment to South Carolina, Hall fell beyond where he would have gone on talent alone, but Bruce Seid says the Brewers are "dedicated" to signing him.
- In the same article, Seid touches on Florida State outfielder D'Vontrey Richardson. Richardson was the backup quarterback at FSU last season, which speaks to the caliber of athlete he is, and indeed, he's a plus-plus runner. That said, his baseball skills are very underdeveloped; he hit .351/.431/.481 for the Seminoles as a freshman before sitting out 2008 to concentrate on football and then playing sparingly and not as well (.304/.371/.405) this year. Basically, think Brent Brewer if he had actually gone to FSU to play football. Still, he's an "exceptional worker", which should help bridge the gap between his tools and on-the-field performance, and he sounds very eager to sign. This could turn out to be an inspired pick.
- Outfielder Khris Davis had a big year at Cal State Fullerton, hitting .336/.423/.664 and leading the team in homers with 16. He was a touted prospect coming out of high school, but his first two years at Fullerton were disappointing, so maybe the Brewers are getting a bit of a bargain here, catching a talented ballplayer as he's rediscovering his game.
- Alabama's Del Howell is a power lefty, featuring a fastball that sits in the low 90s, touches 95, and has good natural sinking movement and complementing the heater with a hard low 80s slider and a promising changeup. Those three quality pitches made him a second- to fourth-round talent and the #105 overall prospect in the draft according to BA, but he slid to the 15th round after catching mono and pitching poorly and because he's got less than 100 collegiate innings under his belt, making his performance that much harder to read. That light workload will be a blessing if he signs, however, considering the wringer many college pitchers are put through by their coaches. Seid confirms that Howell will require a fair chunk of change, probably commensurate with the top-round talent BA rated him as. If the Brewers aren't willing to give him what he wants, he could be The One That Got Away, the Jemile Weeks of 2009. I really want them to sign this guy.
- For the second pick in the row, the Brewers took a top-rated talent that slid, this time Scooter Gennett, a high school shortstop from Florida. He was perhaps among the top 30 high school juniors last year, but his stock fell this year and he was considered a third- to fifth-round talent and ranked #154 overall. BA says he's a second baseman as a pro and that he has "surprising power and bat speed for his size" (5'10"/170), but they didn't like his swing with a wood bat at a recent showcase and quoted an AL scout as saying he'd be better off going to college. He was perceived as having a strong commitment to Florida State and probably unsignable after dropping, but he sounds morineko is sure to be a big fan of his.
- Mississippi high schooler Lex Rutledge, as you'll see in my interview with him tomorrow, expected to be taken in the third round, which speaks to the quality of his three-pitch arsenal. Especially promising is his precocious feel for his changeup. He's also got good velocity from the left side; BA reports him reaching 90 mph, and Rutledge himself says he threw 92 to 94 in front of the Brewers' scout. He'll take third-round money to sign.
- Jacobbi McDaniel might be my favorite pick in the draft. First of all, look at the guy; you don't see many 285-pound third baseman. Indeed, McDaniel wasn't even in Baseball America's draft database and is more well-known for exploits on the gridiron, where he's a five-star defensive tackle recruit for Florida State. That didn't stop the Brewers from drafting him and reportedly offering him $800k to sign. Though McDaniel publicly said it would take $1.5M to sway him from football, he told me that he was 50/50 on whether or not to accept the Brewers' offer. I just want to see him stand next to Prince Fielder.
- If Kyle Hansen's name sounds familiar, it's because he's the younger brother of erstwhile future Red Sox closer Craig Hansen, a first-round pick in 2005. Craig is huge, but at 6'7", Kyle even has an inch on him, though he weighs a scant 190 lbs. BA says he's touched 94 with his fastball and has an inconsistent slider along with a rarely seen changeup and splitter--better stuff than his brother had in high school. Given his height and age, it goes without saying that his mechanics are unrefined. This kind raw, projectable pitcher almost always goes to college, and indeed Kyle is expected to follow Craig to St. John's, but you never know.
- Brad Schreiber is Jordan's high school classmate, and I'll let Jordan tell you about him.
- BA on Richard Stock:
Stock, the younger brother of USC's Robert Stock, has been hobbled by injuries to his wrist, back and ribs. A top 200 prospect when healthy, he figures to follow Robert to USC, where he could develop into one of the nation's finest catchers and a first-round candidate in 2012. He has better size than his older brother at 6-foot-3, 185 pounds, and raw power from the left side to go with above-average arm strength.
He would be another great, if unlikely, sign.
55 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I really like the Howell pick
Definitely need to do what they have to do to get that kid in the system.
My favorites of the Brewer draft include Davis, Cameron Garfield, D’Vontrey Richardson and Scooter Gennett.
I think the two top pitching picks, Arnett and Heckathorn are big injury risks and wind up in the bullpen.
Also a little surprised at how many signability risks the Brewers took. If they can get the majority of them locked up they could wind up being big time steals.
Considering the fact that they are picking at the lowest levels they have since 1983, Id say the draft so far grades at about a C. If Arnett can stay as a starter and stay healthy it goes up to a B. If Heckathorn does well it will wind up as an A.
Based on what?
I think the two top pitching picks, Arnett and Heckathorn are big injury risks and wind up in the bullpen.
I understand that Heckathorn has a “bad pitching motion” but again, that it has been shown that that doesn’t always equate to injury. But what makes you say that about Arnett?
battlekow: Bill is having an oppo-gasm
I have no idea how you can call a pitcher who has not had injuries an injury risk
Not to be antagonistic, but do you think Arnett’s mechanics are bad? That’s no way to predict injuries, really. I’m genuinely curious if you’re just guessing or what.
I last May, still no more than Nick Neugebauer not.
Not quite a guess
But when a player has bad mechanics, injuries are always a concern.
Arnett’s issue is that he has a hard landing on his plant foot, particularly, that he lands hard on his heel. Longtime scout Art Stewart of the KC Royals calls players like him “heel bangers”. Guys who do this have a penchant for developing shoulder problems.
He hasnt had any issues yet, probably, because before this year he was a relief pitcher, and threw less pitches, and put less strain on his arm. But now that he has become a starter, add to the mechanical problem, arm problems could not be too far off.
I'm really skeptical of anyone claiming to be able to forecast injuries based on mechanics
I can understand the relieving thing, but that also means he has less mileage on his arm. I don’t know how you can just say good or bad mechanics when we don’t really know enough to forecast that kind of stuff. You can speculate all you want, but the only good indicator of future pitching injuries is past pitching injuries. Drafting pitching is a crapshoot, and if you take a guy with no past problems, you’re putting yourself in the best position to get success.
I last May, still no more than Nick Neugebauer not.
Im not forecasting
But bad mechanics lead to injuries. And the type of bad mechanic that Arnett has leads to shoulder and back problems.
I would disagree about the only good indicator of pitching injuries statement. When you have a guy that has had injuries that works, but what about the first injury? I would contend that bad mechanics are the thing that forecast that first injury.
Arnett has been healthy so far, but he has not had a great toll placed on his arm yet. He spent his first 2 years at IU in the bullpen and only logged 101 innings. He has almost a free year of use in his arm compared with the average college starting pitcher.
This is a very naive question (I know it's way too early)
But does this say anything as to the ability that Seid has as a scouting director? In other words, did we not lose too much when Jack Z left?
battlekow: Bill is having an oppo-gasm
We lost a lot
but it appears that Seid gets it as well. So it’s not that Jack was easily replaceable, but that Seid is good.
I last May, still no more than Nick Neugebauer not.
Also, I found this scouting report on Gamel to be funny (from the Weeks link)
He’s also considered a solid defender at third base
battlekow: Bill is having an oppo-gasm
HUGE JERRY FAN!!
Seein’ the remaining members of The Dead at the Rothbury Festival in Michigan. Does that make me less of a Jerry fan? ;)
Where have you been Pete? Glad I (maybe?) brought you back to comment here!
You’ve gotta stop being a Brewer Troll (I say that kindly) and come back to this site and comment.
Peace.
battlekow: Bill is having an oppo-gasm
Baby "Prince" playing third?
Our 33rd round pick is Jaccobi McDaniel, 3rd baseman from Madison County HS in Florida. He is listed at 6’0", 285 lbs.
Wow.
For visual reference this guy playing 3B is "listed" at 5'11" 245lbs.
BCB, the preferred above replacement level sarcasm supplier.
by MadJimiBrewha on Jun 11, 2009 11:53 AM CDT up reply actions
Pic Fail, Let's try again

BCB, the preferred above replacement level sarcasm supplier.
by MadJimiBrewha on Jun 11, 2009 11:57 AM CDT up reply actions
Apparently he's a defensive tackle recruit at Florida State
Very highly regarded (as a DT; I can’t imagine anyone likes him as a 3B).
It was a great selection of awesome.
Scouting report
He’s the most athletic big man in the state of Florida for the Class of 2009. His quickness off the ball is very impressive. He doesn’t have to utilize much technique or use too many moves when rushing the passer because he usually wins with straight quickness. He’s a little short but makes up for it with playing with a low center of gravity and just doing a nice job of creating pressure on nearly every snap.
From BK's link
I was just about ot post that….
"To be getting drafted, it was a good thing because I was talking to the scouts before [the draft] and I told them I wasn’t going to go baseball but to get drafted, that’s a good thing," McDaniel said. "… I had told them that but they told me that I still earned the right to be drafted. For that to happen, it’s a good thing."
To pass up the chance to play football at FSU, McDaniel said he’d have to be offered $1.5 million to sign with the Brewers.
"They said they couldn’t do it," McDaniel said.
Weird
I just asked McDaniel
He confirmed that the Brewers offered him $800k.
It was a great selection of awesome.
Though the FSU guy that was here earlier is saying that perhaps he's fibbing in order to drive subscriptions on the site that initally reported the offer
Whatever. We’ll find out soon enough.
It was a great selection of awesome.
Do you know anything about him?
Does anyone? He was ranked #2 in the state by BA, which I felt was garbage, unless he’s throwing in the mid-90s.
I last May, still no more than Nick Neugebauer not.
How did the scouts even see him?
Ladysmith is out where the primary things you’ll find are rocks and trees and trees and rocks and water.. Are they hoping that the Jarrod Washburn variety of lightning strikes twice? (And he came out of the UW system anyway.)
the scouts see everybody
it’s freakish the level of amateur scouting coverage.
Also, cheese.
by Jeff Sackmann on Jun 11, 2009 1:26 PM CDT up reply actions
Cool!
We just drafted Cullen Sexton from the University of Minnesota. He’s from Stevens Point, and we originaly drafted him in the 43rd round in 2007, but he didn’t sign.
It was a great selection of awesome.
From Mayo's twitter
In case you’re wondering, making picks for Brewers is 12-year-old Todd Johnson. Nice job, kid!
Scouting prodigy! ;)
Tidbits I picked up over the course of yesterday
The Brewers talked to Jake Locker about drafting him. Locker is the quarterback at Washington, and baseball teams have been begging him to play their game for a long time. He’d go in the first round if he ever decided to play. The Angels drafted him really late last year but took him again in the 10th round this year, so they must think there’s a possibility of working something out.
The Brewers agreed to draft Keyvius Sampson at #39 but backed out, and he had to wait until the 4th round, where he’ll get half as much money. That kind of thing isn’t unusual at all, but it still kind of sucks for the kid.
It was a great selection of awesome.
Del Howell speaks
"I’m happy to be drafted, but I had hoped for a little better," junior left-hander Howell said. "It’s an honor to be drafted by the Brewers. They have a good organization. I will sit down with everyone and look at things and see what happens as the summer progresses."
link (h/t Brewerfan)
It was a great selection of awesome.
Jordan just spit his Shirley Temple all over the place
he’s still coughing like crazy, out of sheer glee.
Also, cheese.
by Jeff Sackmann on Jun 11, 2009 12:44 PM CDT up reply actions
Does he sign with the hometown team or go to school to hopefully improve his draft spot?
:) + Suppan = :'(
Jordan says his commitment to Purdue is pretty strong but that he's willing to negotiate
The fact that it’s the Brewers can’t hurt.
It was a great selection of awesome.
We'll know more soon
He’s planning on Purdue. But that can change, of course. Maybe I’ll ‘interview’ him.
I last May, still no more than Nick Neugebauer not.
I was cutting lawn hell yes!1!11
We’ll see about this. It can’t hurt.
I last May, still no more than Nick Neugebauer not.
Our first draft signing
Welcome third-rounder Josh Prince to the fold.
It was a great selection of awesome.
Richard Stock in the 45th round is very intriguing
He’s the brother of wunderkind Robert Stock and a USC commit.
It was a great selection of awesome.
Baseball America:
Stock, the younger brother of USC’s Robert Stock, has been hobbled by injuries to his wrist, back and ribs. A top 200 prospect when healthy, he figures to follow Robert to USC, where he could develop into one of the nation’s finest catchers and a first-round candidate in 2012. He has better size than his older brother at 6-foot-3, 185 pounds, and raw power from the left side to go with above-average arm strength.
It was a great selection of awesome.
I'll have a very interesting interview with 26th-rounder Lex Rutledge soon
It was a great selection of awesome.
Lots of signings
Two hours after the Draft concluded, Seid said that the Brewers had already signed or agreed to terms with 20 of their 53 picks. The Brewers typically make official announcements in bunches once the proper paperwork is filed, but the list of players already under contract includes third-round pick Josh Prince, a shortstop from Tulane; sixth-rounder Hiram Burgos, a right-hander from Bethune-Cookman; ninth-rounder Jonathan Pokorny, a left-hander from Kent State; and 10th-rounder Tyler Roberts, a high school catcher from Georgia. In addition, the team had come to terms with second-rounder Max Walla, a high school outfielder from Albuquerque who wowed club officials in a Miller Park workout last weekend, and was close to agreeing with another second-round pick, high school catcher Cameron Garfield.
It was a great selection of awesome.
Nice.
That seems quick, but I know nothing about these things.
by Cheeseandcorn on Jun 11, 2009 11:52 PM CDT up reply actions
Cameron Garfield
went to James A. Garfield High School*, which means they are now Garfield Minus Garfield.
*not actually true.
"I will agree that the attitude [at BCB] is ridiculous and they have done so much to instigate animosity and then block us from responding. Real mature!"
by roguejim on Jun 12, 2009 1:52 AM CDT up reply actions 1 recs
post
Someone should make a post of all signed players like we had last year





























