Today's trio features at least one guy the Brewers will interview for sure, along with one that's expressed interest:
- Former Diamondbacks manager Bob Melvin.
- Former Orioles interim manager Juan Samuel.
- Former Mariners manager Don Wakamatsu.
The basics: Melvin was a ten year major leaguer between seven teams from 1985-94, then spent a few seasons as a scout and in the Brewer front office before becoming Phil Garner's bench coach in 1999. He joined Garner in Detroit in 2000 and spent a couple of years on staff with the Diamondbacks before joining the Mariners as manager in 2003.
Melvin managed the Mariners for two seasons and the Diamondbacks for most of five, compiling a 493-508 record with one playoff appearance (2007).
Brewer connection: As mentioned above, Melvin is a former scout and coach for the Brewers.
Scouting report: This report comes from Jim McLennan of AZ Snakepit.
The basics: Samuel was a 16-year major leaguer, playing for seven teams before retiring after the 1998 season. After retirement, he spent six years on the Tigers' coaching staff, one year managing in the minors for the Mets, and four years coaching third base for the Orioles.
Samuel managed 51 games for the Orioles this season between the firing of Dave Trembley and the hiring of Buck Showalter, and went 17-34.
Brewer connection: None
Scouting Report: This report comes from Stacey of Camden Chat.
It is tough to evaluate Juan Samuel‘s managerial skills in Baltimore as he was hired to be fired. Samuel knew he didn’t have a chance at the permanent position, the players knew he was a placeholder, and the fans were counting the days until his replacement came along. Did he do things the way he wanted or was he just keeping the seat warm? Did he try to implement changes that the players resisted because he was essentially a substitute teacher? There’s just no way to know.
When Samuel replaced Dave Trembley as manager for the Orioles on June 4th, he didn’t change anything about the way the Orioles had been doing business. He didn’t change the lineup and he didn’t make any decisions that varied from what Trembley would have done in the same situation. Considering Trembley had just been fired, it didn’t seem like much of a strategy for getting the bosses to notice his skills. But again, Samuel knew from the time he was hired that the Orioles didn’t want him, so perhaps that had something to do with it. And the Orioles didn’t waste much time, hiring Buck Showalter to replace Samuel after just fifty-one games.
So what kind of manager was Samuel for those fifty-one games? It seemed more often than not he was the kind of manager that got into his own way too often. He relied on, for lack of a better term, traditional lines of thinking, but took them to such extremes that it seemed silly. He often pinch ran in a tie game for the team’s best hitter, bunted with runners already in scoring position, asked players like Matt Wieters to bunt when the next two hitters in the lineup couldn’t reach base if a gun was held to their head . Things like that. It’s probably a common complaint by fans regarding the manager as we all have the benefit of hindsight, but there were many times when, in the moment, it seemed that nobody really understood why Samuel was doing what he was doing.
Without knowing much specifically about the Brewers, it is possible that Samuel’s style will be more suited to the National League where the manager is required to be more involved in the on-field events, what with pitchers hitting and double switches and small ball and whatever other crazy things happen in the NL. He is certainly very respected around baseball for his knowledge of the game, and given a clean slate where he knows the job is his, he might thrive.
The basics: Wakamatsu played just one major league season (18 games with the '91 White Sox) and 12 minor league seasons, retiring in 1996. After his playing career was over, he spent four seasons as a minor league manager in the Diamondbacks and Angels organizations, five years on the Rangers' staff (four of them as bench coach) and one year as the A's bench coach.
He opened the 2009 season as the manager of the Mariners, and went 127-147 before being fired halfway through 2010.
Brewer connection: Wakamatsu's final professional appearance came with the New Orleans Zephyrs (then a Brewer affiliate) in 1996. He appeared in just one game with the Zephyrs, and did not bat.
Scouting Report: Here's Jeff Sullivan of Lookout Landing.
Which of these candidates most deserve to be considered for the Brewers' managerial vacancy?
Bob Melvin (86 votes)
Juan Samuel (15 votes)
Don Wakamatsu (48 votes)
None of these should be considered. (175 votes)
324 total votes