MACHAWATCH! August 19, 2010 Edition.
So, if the Brewers had blown that 3-0 lead in the bottom of the ninth yesterday, after Randy Wolf was yanked after giving out a one-out, Braun-aided "double" (cough, cough) and John Axford was inserted into the game a day after throwing 26 pitches in a 1.2 inning save ... would today have been a more interesting off-day for manager Ken Macha and MACHAWATCH!?
I'm not saying it's a given, not at all -- but had the Brewers blown that game, I could see cranky owner calling up his beleaguered GM, saying: "What in the HELL was that all about?" and demanding a change.
The world will never know.
There's no change in the nullacct Managerometer again, so I won't post the picture. Instead, I want to share with you something that nullacct was nice enough to share with me a few weeks ago; I think you'll know when it's appropriate to summon this particular weapon from the arsenal. May it be a light for you in dark places:
After the jump: we're talkin' bullpen (again) and bean balls (again) and @notkenmacha (as always). Won't you join us?
This Week in Bean Ball Hijinks: Brewer-related, this particular item ain't, so let's get it out of the way first: in the first inning of yesterday's Tigers-Yankees tilt in the Bronx, Detroit starter Jeremy Bonderman pegged Yankee centerfielder Brett Gardner in the leg, presumably in retaliation for Gardner's hard slide into Carlos Guillen the night before, which bruised Guillen's knee and landed him on the DL.
As you'd expect, both benches are immediately warned by home plate umpire Eric Cooper, which made it all the more curious when Cooper didn't toss New York's Chad Gaudin when Gaudin tattooed Miggy Cabrera between the shoulder blades to open the eighth. But even more more curious was Cooper's decision not to toss Detroit's Enrique Gonzalez in the bottom of the eighth after Gonzalez threw behind Derek Jeter.
Mighty fine deterrent effect that first-inning warning had there, Coop.
Folks, this whole situation is a mess, and baseball's attempts to stop the shenanigans border on the farcical. I don't know what the answer is -- if we tell the umpires to butt out of it and let the teams police themselves, we're inviting lunatics like Tony LaRussa to go ever more overboard with this beanball nonsense. If we try to narrow the discretion of the umpires -- by, say, ordering immediate ejections for any HBP after a warning is issued -- some pitchers who don't deserve to get ejected are going to get run.
Any suggestions?
This Week in Swinging Loe and a Dulling Ax: On Monday, KL did a fine job detailing Kameron Loe's absurd workload in the 2010 season; including the just-completed series against St. Louis, Kam has made 35 appearances in the two-and-one-half months since being called up from Nashville, with fifteen (15) of those appearances lasting more than one inning. Unsurprisingly, given that workload and given that he'd probably been overperforming for his first two months with the Brewers, Loe's started to show some fraying at the edges in the last couple weeks.
Of course, Loe's not the only one being asked to shoulder a heavier yoke in the 'pen this year. Closer John Axford has made 34 appearances in the three months since he was summoned from AAA, with nine (9) of those appearances covering more than one inning. And you might remember that, before he was banished to AAA at the end of July, Carlos Villanueva pitched in 42 games for the Crew -- including twenty-five (25) appearances in April and May alone.
On the other side of the coin, David Riske has made a mere twenty-two (22) appearances since he returned from injury at the beginning of June, and Chris Capuano has made just thirteen (13) relief appearances since his first appearance on June 3. Zach Braddock's stuff suggests that he shouldn't be pigeonholed as a situational lefty, but he's been used like one, pitching less than one inning in fourteen (14) of his 30 appearances.
I was concerned a couple of weeks back that Macha was going to continue to abuse his top performers in the 'pen, despite the fact that this season is a lost cause and that, by all appearances, there's nothing Macha can do to save his job at this point.
I'm very, very concerned now.
This Week in @notkenmacha: And because I'm very, very concerned now, I asked our fake skipper what, exactly, he was trying to accomplish by pitching Kam Loe every damn day. Is he trying to kill the Snake King?
Hey Rachel:
Your question pisses me off.
Who the hell is Kam Loe and why should I give two craps about him? Also, Kenneth Eugene Macha does not "try" to kill people, he kills people. If I wanted to kill Ken Snow, I just would walk past him, drinking a can of Ocean Spray Cran-Apple, and when I finished I would simply grab his bottom jaw and push my empty can through the back of his throat.
Incidentally, I invented the concept of "product-placement" back during the Cold War in the 1950s. Ocean Spray would pay me $10 for every communist that I killed with a can of their products. I would receive a bonus $5.50 if the newspaper would report that the target died looking "refreshed and satisfied".
What is getting on my last nerves though, are the chuckleheads at County Stadium giving me guff about my usage of relief pitchers. In the off-season Don Melvin asked me what I needed to make this team work, and I replied "Dawn, I need some quality pitchers for our bullpen". Well, I sent Melvin to the 7-11 for some pooper-paper and he brought back porcupines. Am I to blame that we don't have a pitcher in our bullpen that can outs when our team needs them?
As a side note, one summer when I was playing ball in the Ozark Recreational League, Ed Ott and I purchased some "Quality Aged Taco Bell" burritos, and had to make a run to the border (if you know what I mean) while we were enjoying a nature ride through West Memphis. The only thing we could find to clean our backsides were a family of porcupines. We learned quickly to wipe "with" the quills and never "against" -- or what is know in the baseball bedroom circles as "Tony Curtising".
This whole poppycock has me in a zim-zam. If you would excuse me, I am going to march my ass over to the front office -- I am thirsty, I have a six-pack of Ocean Spray, and I could use $15.50.
Baseballingly Yours,
Kenneth
P.S. Tony Curtis Sucks
42 comments
|
3 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Want to read a long-winded defense of Macha?
You came to the right place (and I was really bored on my lunch break):
PECOTA projected the Brewers to win 76 games this year. Right now they are on pace to win 76 games.
Macha has had an eye on the future and has been playing Lucroy and Escobar regularly despite some offensive and defensive struggles. He’s also stuck with Manny Parra in the rotation despite Manny being pretty bad. All indications are he’s going to give Cain lot of playing time. He was stuck with Hoffman at closer, but didn’t give him the job back when he was "fixed" and stuck with a rookie. He was stuck with Jeff Suppan and only gave him 2 starts before banishing him to the bullpen. Basically, I’ve been impressed that he is for the most part, letting the young guys play and not giving Counsell or Inglett regular starts because they are gritty veterans. He wasn’t afraid to sit Hart when he was awful in spring training, yet quick to put him back in the lineup when he started to hit.
His lineups have been pretty much what I would have done, though I think there will always be small quibbles no matter who the manager is.
I’m having a hard time buying that using Kam Loe or Axford too much is that big of issue – I don’t think fans really have any idea how this is going to affect their future performance and if it’s a decision between letting a good pitcher pitch or letting a bad pitcher pitch (Riske/Cappy), I’m fine going with the better pitchers. Braddock had a "dead arm" problem earlier in the year, I’m OK letting him work less than one inning and or only against left-handed strong lineups. Next year, I’d expect a larger role. The Brewers have an average bullpen, not even the greatest manager in the world can turn it into a great one.
So that’s my justification. I’m still quite pissed about the Gamel thing from last year, but it seems like most of the criticism is sort of nit-picky or the vague "he’s not firing up the troops enough" "they don’t look sharp" or whatever is always thrown out there when the team is losing. I think he has taken the roster that he was given and played right about to expectations. I won’t be heartbroken if they let Macha go at the end of the year, but also will be fine if they bring him back another year.
So there it is. I know the majority of people who read the site disagree strongly with me so have at it, just thought I’d play the contrarian.
Get a ife broseph
by Supertramp on Aug 19, 2010 12:36 PM CDT reply actions 3 recs
"Macha has had an eye on the future and has been playing Lucroy and Escobar regularly despite some offensive and defensive struggles"
or because there were literally no other options.
http://www.twitter.com/mykenk
Right.
It would have been interesting if JEd hadn’t been traded. Based on what happened last year, I bet he’d be splitting starts with LoCain for the rest of the year.
SRS BSNS
Not sure
Melvin said Edmonds was reluctant at first but realized the Brewers were committed to playing newcomer Lorenzo Cain as much as possible the rest of the way.
“He saw with Lorenzo here that his playing time might decrease,” said Melvin.
http://www.jsonline.com/sports/brewers/100318999.html
Get a ife broseph
I think what you are saying here is that he is average?
And as far as Loe and the Ax man go – we will see how they end the season. At this point I would rather see them finish with 72 wins if it kept them from abusing those two.
by BrewCrewBrian on Aug 19, 2010 12:49 PM CDT up reply actions
And hope they're as effective next year,
which is far from a guarantee.
http://www.twitter.com/mykenk
Since when is abuse=shutting them down ?!?!?!?!
by BrewCrewBrian on Aug 19, 2010 12:56 PM CDT up reply actions
If you want to not abuse them,
why not shut them down? Give other people a shot for the rest of the meaningless year, as we’ve established that results don’t mean anything.
http://www.twitter.com/mykenk
There is a huge difference between abuse and shutting them down!
I think most people here would agree that Macha has abused them over the last month because he didn’t have anything better.
I would rather see them get regular work, and pitch the other guys so they get regular work.
by BrewCrewBrian on Aug 19, 2010 1:03 PM CDT up reply actions
There's a happy medium
between “treat it like a Little League game” and “treat it like it’s the third game of the World Series,” isn’t there?
SRS BSNS
Axford has pitched 9.2 innings in August, and averaged 12.2 IP in June and July. Is he really being overused or just getting attention because he is doing something different than other “closers” who only throw 1 inning?
No denying Loe is pitching a lot, but he’s a 29 year old relief pitcher with a spotty record of success. I’ll concede this point, but still don’t think its a big deal.
Get a ife broseph
It's a fair point.
The number of pitches Axford is throwing concerns me more than the innings; if my math is right, he’s at 113 pitches in the last seven days.
SRS BSNS
starters throw ~140/wk
admittedly a reliever likely throws more in the pen
by PagsBrewCrew on Aug 19, 2010 1:19 PM CDT up reply actions
For me it is more pitches as well
It seems like they pitch him a ton in stretches, and then let him sit for long stretches. This making a month too long of a time frame to look at.
by BrewCrewBrian on Aug 19, 2010 1:20 PM CDT up reply actions
Doesn't that happen with a lot of relief pitchers?
i.e. pitch a lot at certain times then sit for a few days.
I don’t have any idea the effect of sitting for X amount of days or how many pitches per week is too many for Axford, I don’t think many fans do.
Get a ife broseph
He's had days off in there though
35 pitches, day off, 33, off, off, 26, 19.
Still a lot of pitches, but I don’t know if it’s terribly worrisome. There was a stretch at the end of July and beginning of August where he threw 30 pitches over something like 10-12 days. I think it’s cyclical and they haven’t been riding him so hard all this time.
He’s been wild lately. Maybe that’s because he’s pitched a lot, or maybe he’s going back to the 6 BB/9 pitcher he was in the minors. For a while he wasn’t walking anyone and he had low pitch counts even in five-out saves. Now he’s walking people while being used for five-out saves and it looks bad.
Just a random thought. When Hoffman is gone next year, Axford will be used one inning at a time. Right now they can use him for five-out saves because they have a backup closer if he runs into trouble. Next year they won’t have that luxury (no matter how much we point to Braddock, et al.).
Maybe he should play first base instead. That is, he should lie out there and we can step on him when we get a hit.
You don't think Braddock can do what Hoffman has done?
I thought originally Axford ’wasn’t the closer type’ and it was going to be Braddock’s job in 2011. Has everything changed?
I was more going for the "Braddock has never closed so he's not a closer" mindset
That seems prevalent in baseball.
Personally, I think Braddock (or another pitcher who hasn’t been a closer) would do fine in the ninth inning. I just don’t think baseball managers operate that way until they have no other options.
Maybe he should play first base instead. That is, he should lie out there and we can step on him when we get a hit.
thought that he had in 2009 or 2010 in AAA?
or was that strictly smith? who filled in when smith was on the MLB club?
by PagsBrewCrew on Aug 19, 2010 3:20 PM CDT up reply actions
Regardless, AAA is not the same as MLB
I don’t think that just because Braddock or whoever closed games in AAA, a major league manager would put him in a closer role. Maybe I’m wrong about that, but they didn’t seem to trust Chris Smith.
I think it far more likely that if Axford remains as the closer, whoever takes Hoffman’s spot becomes a setup man at best and Axford goes to the ninth inning only where there isn’t need/time for a backup closer.
Maybe he should play first base instead. That is, he should lie out there and we can step on him when we get a hit.
To be fair
Axford was put into the closer role without having any experience at the MLB level, so I don’t think it would be that much of a stretch for them to also use Braddock similarly.
Pujols is the Barack Obama of baseball.
He was groomed as a starter earlier in his career
Don’t be surprised if he’s given a shot as a 5th starter next spring..
Statistics: A bunch of numbers looking around for an argument. G. Burgy, Rockville, MD
by heybatterbatter on Aug 19, 2010 6:31 PM CDT up reply actions
I'm referring to LOE in the post above.
Statistics: A bunch of numbers looking around for an argument. G. Burgy, Rockville, MD
by heybatterbatter on Aug 19, 2010 6:33 PM CDT up reply actions
Excellent points
This is the sort of thing that I think about when voting in the weekly polls. There’s the overall job that Macha has done this season, but then there’s the odd things that he does from time-to-time in games which frustrates everyone.
I will say that the recent performances we’re seeing with Loe and Axford can be attributed (to some degree) are due to overuse. I also think that some of it is also related to them coming back down to reality.
That’s why I end up selecting “Undecided” every time the poll comes up.
Pujols is the Barack Obama of baseball.
He should turn over the field duties to Randolph
Handle personnel issues and keep an eye on the game, work with the kids in practice. Use Sveum and Peterson to hone skills, and then turn the games over to Randolph and just watch and take notes.
Heh...
some days it seems like Macha is doing just that… just watching and taking notes. :)
Not sure what Macha does during practice, but it seems like Randolph is pretty hands on… working with Weeks on defense, working on bunting, etc.
Pujols is the Barack Obama of baseball.
We’re talking about practice man. We’re talking about practice. We’re talking about practice. We’re not talking about the game. We’re talking about practice.
by BrewCrewBrian on Aug 19, 2010 4:23 PM CDT up reply actions
Not just Weeks, and not just defense.
Randolph was brought on almost expressly to work with Rickie last year, right before he began to break out offensively and when he became less bad defensively. Randolph also was working closely with McGehee before he broke out last season, and also with Lopez when he posted career numbers as a Brewer. He’s working with Escobar, turning him into a complete baseball player. Even if that’s a work in progress, the results are starting to come around.
Randolph doesn’t seem to get any credit for these things, which is especially surprising considering these were the things he was originally brought on to do. I would think that, moving forward, if you want Gamel and Lawrie to become average infielders defensively while maximizing their potential offensively, I’d say Randolph is your man. Whether that means you keep him as bench coach and hope nobody else signs him away, or you give him the reins in 2011 and beyond, he seems like he’s had a huge positive impact on the team and would continue to do so with a more influential position.
Good point
Still, if Randolph does get the managerial job, would he still have time to work with the players hands-on? As the bench coach, he has time to that, but if he’s manager, I would think that the additional responsibilities would limit his time to work one-on-one with players.
Pujols is the Barack Obama of baseball.
Dilbert principle?
or Peter principle? I can’t remember which. People rise in organizations to their level of incompetence.
If Randolf is doing well, hopefully he’s content to remain where he’s at. Because if he is promoted, he likely won’t have time (other than in ST) for all the things he’s able to accomplish now.
by PagsBrewCrew on Aug 20, 2010 11:34 AM CDT up reply actions
I agree with this
I think Macha has been great this year with the lineups and playing time. I do think he has relied on his top relievers a bit too much but I wouldn’t call it abuse either. He’s been a gigantic improvement over Yost (not hard, admittedly) and I honestly don’t know if we’ll find anyone who will do better when we search for our new manager this offseason.
by kingcharlesxii on Aug 19, 2010 1:30 PM CDT up reply actions
You got a link to this? Kinda important for me. I have a PECOTA bet with somebody.
PECOTA projected the Brewers to win 76 games this year.
Yeah, well, sometimes I drink.
by Dikembe Meiztombo on Aug 19, 2010 3:04 PM CDT up reply actions
I couldn’t find past PECOTA standings on BP.com, but based it off of the link Kyle referenced in the March 1st Mug, which was the closest to opening day I could find.
http://www.brewcrewball.com/2010/3/1/1331327/mondays-frosty-mug
Get a ife broseph
"@notkenmacha as always"
you were counting on the drinking to kill our long term memory brain cells, weren’t you?

by 



































