MVBrewers #7: Nyjer Morgan
When Corey Hart got hurt in Spring Training and Doug Melvin went looking for outfield depth, no one could have imagined it would work out like this.
In fact, the first comment of the Fan Shot announcing the trade for Nyjer Morgan is Kyle saying "I have no idea why anyone would do this."
At the time, we felt we were basically trading Chris Dickerson for Nyjer Morgan as the 3rd/4th outfielder. There were those who were concerned that we were moving on from Brandon Boggs and/or Jeremy Reed. Sadly, we also thought the acquisition might mean the end of Mark Kotsay - if only. At the time, Doug Melvin said the move was a protection in case anything happened to Carlos Gomez and he told Gomez the trade wasn't made to take away Gomez's job.
People's hesitation over Morgan had a lot to do with his poor 2010 - he had a career-worst BA by .040. His slugging was.060 lower and his OPS nearly .100 lower than any other time in his career.
Of course, Morgan hit .455/.500/.727 with an OPS of 1.227 in March and April while Carlos Gomez hit .240/.278/.320 with an OPS of .598. Morgan started getting the larger share of games in June and it went from there.
While Morgan couldn't keep up that pace, he did end with a final line of .304/.357/.421 - that BA was second on the team.
He almost instantly became a fan favorite and, somewhat inexplicably, his appeal ranged from children to grandparents. His (and Tony Plush's) merchandise was the best-selling at Miller Park this season and a game didn't go past where I didn't see someone my parent's age wearing a T. Plush shirsey.
Maybe it was because of the many memorable post-game interviews, but it sure did feel like Morgan had more "big" moments this season than some of the other guys on the team.
There was the June 8 walk-off double that Nyjer didn't realize was a walk-off to beat the Mets 7-6. This was the advent of the crazy Tony Plush dugout interview that we saw throughout the season and gave us the "Ahhhh! Gotta Go!"
You'll remember the July 2 game as the one where the Brewers were down 7-0 to the Twins and came back to win it 8-7 with four runs in the ninth. It was a particularly big game for Morgan, who was 3-for-5 with 3 runs and 4 RBI, including a two-out, ninth inning, game-tying two-run double.
There was the ninth-inning triple on July 8 that sparked the rally to beat the Reds 8-7. And a two-run bunt single in Colorado on July 16 that scored two runs in the fifth and helped bust a slump for the team.
And the most memorable of all, 10th-inning, series-clinching, walk-off single in Game 5 of the NLDS. Despite hitting just .179 in the post-season, Morgan managed to make an indelible mark - much like he did the rest of the year.
Aside from the on-field sparks, Morgan was clearly a firework in the clubhouse. He became the poster-child for Beast Mode. After the September 23 division-clinch, he walked around in a SWAT helmet. On August 2, MLB Network's Intentional Talk did an interview with Ryan Braun and Prince Fielder where Morgan stood in the background and provided their security. Whether it's Tony Plush, Antonio Picante, Tony Gumbel or Tony Hush, he provided the best post-game interviews we've ever seen in Milwaukee.
Best Game: While other games might have been statistically better, Morgan had no bigger game that NLDS Game 5. In 20 years, its possible no one will talk about "Throwing up the T" or Beast Mode, but few of us will ever forget the Brewers winning their first post-season series since 1982 and Morgan was the one that delivered it.
Here's the video of that walk-off moment:
Contract details: Morgan had a one-year $450,000 contract for 2011 and this off-season is the first year he is arbitration eligible. The Brewers will likely offer him arbitration, which he will be required to accept. The league will set a hearing date and he and the team will have until that date to come to a contract agreement. With Doug Melvin's history of signing arbitration-eligible players, it seems doubtful he will make it to his hearing, but you never know.
31 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I just can't see
Why anyone would argue that it would be the right thing to offer Morgan a multi-year contract. I love him as much as the next guy, but it’s still Nyjer Morgan. Take him to arbitration. He loves being here, lets just take it a year at a time with a wildcard like him.
Don't sweat the petty things, and don't pet the sweaty things.
Maybe a 2 year deal with more money coming in 2013
Thus allowing them to have extra payroll in 2012? I dunno, that’s about all I got.
Get a ife broseph
I suppose if it saves money
but I still don’t like it.
Don't sweat the petty things, and don't pet the sweaty things.
by Grim Spandango on Nov 2, 2011 2:47 PM CDT up reply actions
You would probably have to really low ball him
And hope that he would come in with an outrageous arb offer from his side, to save money on a multi year deal.
Although horribly inconsistent so far during his career he has put up 2 4 WAR type seasons. Add his age in there, and he’s definitely not a $5 million arb award winner type.
Would you want to give the guy 2 years for $9 million? Because that is what a 40% and 60% arb award would look like for a 2 WAR player, which is probably what you can realistically expect from him.
If you take him to arb Id be willing to bet he gets a $2 million type deal for next year and if he blows away like he did this year maybe double again in 2013 is only $6 million or so.
He’s just a really odd case when it comes to what to expect in arbitration.
He's really not been horribly inconsistent though
2007: .348 wOBA
2008: .320 wOBA
2009: .340 wOBA
2010: .287 wOBA
2011: .346 wOBA
He had a bad 2010, but the rest has been pretty consistent.
Get a ife broseph
'07 and '08 werent full seasons
and ’07 was really just a cup of coffee….
maybe “wildly” is too harsh. But he is of an advanced age compared to a lot of first year arb eligible players, and there is also the 3 franchises in 3 years issue to factor in. Obviously those arent things that go into an arbitration case, but it woulf if I wanted to offer hm a multiyear deal.
I dont think 2/$5 million would be too horrible, but would he take that deal? It will be very interesting to see what type of Free Agency he will have after the 2014 season. He’s not the type of guy that generally gets overpaid.
Eh, he can only play the cards he was dealt
Every year he’s been given time (sans 2010) he’s produced. I get the concerns over consistency, but think its overblown a bit.
Comparing him to other players in Arb, he’ll always be an outlier because of his late start in baseball. Because of his age and unique path to the majors, its hard to know what he would expect to get.
Get a ife broseph
That picture at the top
Might be the lasting image of this year’s team for me. Intense, confident, exciting, and downright fun.
So the 7th most valuable player on the team
was a platoon player that was so valuable to the team that RRR decided to start Mark Kotsay ON THE ROAD in the NLCS? He didn’t hit lefties and while good defensively, he pales in comparison to Gomez in this aspect.
There is no way Plush was more valuable as a platoon player than Hart and Weeks were playing against RHP all season. Those guys didn’t get to cherry pick favorable pitching matchups and hide against the tough ones. Plush also hit right in front of 8 and 28. Lots of good pitches to hit in that comfy spot.
Finally, it was Plush declaring the Cardinals dead on Twitter that, IMHO, started the karma induced downfall to the Cards in the first place. Terrible job here by the knowledgeable BCB fan base.
A quick session of fungos is all Mat Gamel needs to play 3rd base for the Milwaukee Brewers.
by Brew Town Boozer on Nov 2, 2011 7:10 PM CDT reply actions 2 recs
No.
Just think a popularity contest got in the way of common sense and simply pointed it out and my reasons why.
A quick session of fungos is all Mat Gamel needs to play 3rd base for the Milwaukee Brewers.
by Brew Town Boozer on Nov 2, 2011 7:29 PM CDT up reply actions 2 recs
You listed "karma induced downfall" as a reason Morgan wasn't valuable
Then complain common sense wasn’t used by others?
Gotcha.
Get a ife broseph
Uh.
I listed the real reasons and ended with my own personal reason. I didn’t say he wasn’t valuable. I said he wasn’t as valuable as Hart or Weeks.
A quick session of fungos is all Mat Gamel needs to play 3rd base for the Milwaukee Brewers.
by Brew Town Boozer on Nov 2, 2011 7:43 PM CDT up reply actions 1 recs
Oh,
I didn’t realize I had to pass the Supertramp test of validity to post a comment about an opinion I have attained.
A quick session of fungos is all Mat Gamel needs to play 3rd base for the Milwaukee Brewers.
by Brew Town Boozer on Nov 3, 2011 5:43 PM CDT up reply actions
Sorry
But how in the world is voting for Nyjer Morgan for the 7th Most Valuable Brewer a ‘popularity contest’? I could see if he was in the top 3 maybe.
"Obi Braun Kenobi you're our only hope!"
by ObiBraunKenobi on Nov 3, 2011 1:08 AM CDT up reply actions
You don't honestly think
Nyjer Morgan would be 7th without the T Plush moniker and his goofy shenanigans, do you? His numbers are inferior to Corey Hart, even with Plush’s ridiculously high BABIP. Also, no need to apologize to me for having an opinion.
A quick session of fungos is all Mat Gamel needs to play 3rd base for the Milwaukee Brewers.
by Brew Town Boozer on Nov 3, 2011 7:17 AM CDT up reply actions 1 recs
FanG has him as the #4 offensive player by WAR
He’s an above average hitter, fielder, and baserunner who made the most of a platoon role with a great attitude and excellent clutch hitting. I consider that valuable.
Once again
for those that can’t read something I have posted now 3 times. I AM NOT SAYING PLUSH ISN’T VALUABLE. What I am saying he isn’t as valuable as the everyday right fielder that hit 26 homers and the everyday second baseman who hits fifth behind Prince, or lead off.
A quick session of fungos is all Mat Gamel needs to play 3rd base for the Milwaukee Brewers.
by Brew Town Boozer on Nov 3, 2011 5:46 PM CDT up reply actions
One more thing
If Plush possesses these characteristics, then why wasn’t he the lead off hitter? You know who was this season? Hart and Weeks for the VAST majority of games. I like Plush and I’m a Plush guy. But I don’t consider my best bunting platoon player to be more valuable than my everyday RF that hit 26 homes and if their OBP is even.
A quick session of fungos is all Mat Gamel needs to play 3rd base for the Milwaukee Brewers.
by Brew Town Boozer on Nov 3, 2011 5:54 PM CDT up reply actions
The sorry was being polite to Obiwan
but you can go ahead and be a dick if you want. It’s called an opinion.
A quick session of fungos is all Mat Gamel needs to play 3rd base for the Milwaukee Brewers.
by Brew Town Boozer on Nov 3, 2011 5:48 PM CDT up reply actions
Not to mention
Weeks missed over a month of the season and when he came back, wasnt nearly the player he was before he got hurt. Hart on the other hand was inconsistent all year and again, struggled to hit sliders as ususal. Morgan on the other hand, was in a platoon, but was the primary starter once Gomez went down, and was nothing but consistent and clutch until September. So, yeah, I’ve got no problem with him being #7, and frankly I’m a little surprised he’s not higher.
He’s actually underrated, but that’s another can of worms…
A good point about Weeks
But Hart hit 26 HRs and had the same OBP as Plush? Inconsistent? That’s Hart’s game.
You are the first person in this thread to actually state why Morgan was more valuable than Hart and Weeks. Not one other person made a case, other than to say I am wrong. Or to chime in with no substance like a dickhead, aka Cwolf20.
Not one person brought up Hairston either and his role at 2B and CF. Remember when Hart was an All Star hitting in front of Braun and Fielder? Once again, if Plush was so awesome he would play against lefties and he would have batted lead off when Rickie got hurt. He didn’t because he was a PART TIME PLAYER. Part time players aren’t the 7th most valuable player on a playoff team.
A quick session of fungos is all Mat Gamel needs to play 3rd base for the Milwaukee Brewers.
by Brew Town Boozer on Nov 4, 2011 6:57 AM CDT up reply actions
Most CF pale in comparison to Gomez on defense.
As far as the really really really bad decision to start Kotsay in CF, Morgan doesn’t decide who plays. The manager has an irrational man crush on Kotsay or Kotsay knows where the bodies are buried.
The best argument against Morgan is the platoon argument. His defense may have made up the difference when he faced LHP but he still may have hurt his WAR by trying to hit LHP. I almost wish we had the opportunity to vote for Gomez/Morgan as a platoon nstead of each individually.
Give him an offspeed pitch down and in. He will swing and miss.
I think honestly we can drop the "most" even
Gomez had 16 defensive runs saved this year, in like 52 games. The highest CF in baseball had 22…for a full season.
by Archibaldcrane on Nov 3, 2011 1:48 PM CDT up reply actions
No doubt.
I think most teams would be hard pressed to match our CF production this year.
Give him an offspeed pitch down and in. He will swing and miss.
I may have voted the platoon #2 ahead of Fielder.
Give him an offspeed pitch down and in. He will swing and miss.

by 





































