Around SBN: Race to the BCS: rankings, in-game scores & blogs Bar-right-arrows


Tn48

brewfan2

Mar 30, 2008 Jan 08, 2009 1 910

a fan of

Milwaukee Brewers Major League Baseball Team

Green Bay Packers National Football League Team

Wisconsin Badgers NCAA Men's Football Division 1A Team

rss icon RSSUser Blog

Cubs Vs. Brewers

Everyone is obviously, picking the Cubs to win this division, but I thought I would compare our players with the cubs players at each position. I really don't know how to adequately compare them, so I'm going to use an arbitrary 1-5 number system. Maybe I'll get crazy and throw some decimals in there. Consider this an overall grade, with an obvious bias towards offense. My numbers equate to 2.5=average  3+=very good  4+=All Star  5=Hall of Fame

Catcher:
Kendall 2.2
Soto      2.6

1st Base:
Fielder  4.5
Lee        3.7

2nd Base:
Weeks   2.9
Derosa  2.5

3rd Base:
Hall         2.8
Ramirez 4.2

Shortstop:
Hardy      3.2
Theriot    2.8

Left Field:
Braun      4.4
Soriano   4.4

Centerfield:
Cameron/Gwynn   3.4
Pie/Johnson            2.8

Right Field:
Hart                 3.9
Fukudome      2.8

Ace:
Sheets              3.6
Zambrano        4.2

#2 Pitcher:
Gallardo         3.9
Lilly                 3.7

#3 Pitcher:
Suppan           2.7
Hill                  3.6

#4 Pitcher:
Bush                2.4
Dempster       2.9

#5 Pitcher:
Villy/Manny    3.4
Marquis           2.8

Closer:
Gagne               3.8
Wood                3.6

Setup:
Turnbow           3.3
Marmol             4.2

Riske                  3.6
Howry                3.9

Mota                  2.9
Lieber                2.5

Shouse               3.1
Hart                    2.6

Torres                3.5
Wuertz               3.7

That's what I've come up with. I really tried to be as objective as possible, but my Cubs hatred runs pretty deep.

Here are the final tallies:
Brewers:  63.5
Cubs:       63.5

I really did not mean for the numbers to be exact, but I guess that shows what kind of season we have in front of us.

Feel free to agree or rip apart any of these rankings.

23 comments | 0 recs

Site Meter