Somehow I never discovered this page until just a few days ago, but it looks to have oddles of fun for everyone. You may start by checking out player pages for Geoff Jenkins, Dan Kolb, Bill Hall, or Derrick Turnbow.
The player search function leaves a lot to be desired--but if you're willing to hunt down the guys you want in the alphabetical list, the rewards are great. Note also the full game logs back to 2002. Even better are the full-length articles by site creator David Appelman, like this one about Ryan Franklin, the new 5th starter for the Philadelphia Phillies.