clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Most Brewer Coaches Should Return for 2011, According to BCB Tracking Poll

New, 9 comments

This week's poll was open from Monday at noon until Wednesday morning, and received 299 responses. Here are some of the notable results:

  • Voters expressed strong disapproval of Doug Melvin, Ken Macha and Rick Peterson's work in 2010 with negative ratings at 55%, 81% and 54%, respectively.
  • 91% of voters agreed with the decision not to retain Ken Macha as manager.
  • Voters feel that most of Macha's coaching staff should remain, however: Rick Peterson, Dale Sveum, Ed Sedar and Stan Kyles all received at least a plurality of "Yes" votes*.
  • Third base coach Brad Fischer was the only coach readers voted not to retain, with 63% saying he should be let go.

* - Willie Randolph was accidentally omitted from the poll.

Follow the jump for the full results.

Do you approve of the job Doug Melvin did as General Manager of the Brewers in 2010?
Response
Votes
%
Yes
101
34%
No
163
55%
Undecided
35
12%

Should Doug Melvin return as General Manager of the Brewers for 2011?

Response
Votes
%
Yes
177
59%
No
84
28%
Undecided
38
13%

Do you approve of the job Ken Macha did as Manager of the Brewers in 2010?

Response
Votes
%
Yes
37
12%
No
243
81%
Undecided
19
6%

Should the Brewers have retained Ken Macha for 2011?

Response
Votes
%
Yes
12
4%
No
272
91%
Undecided
15
5%

Do you approve of the job Rick Peterson did as Pitching Coach of the Brewers in 2010?

Response
Votes
%
Yes
75
25%
No
161
54%
Undecided
63
21%

Should Rick Peterson return as Pitching Coach of the Brewers for 2011?

Response
Votes
%
Yes
131
44%
No
123
41%
Undecided
45
15%

Should Dale Sveum return as Hitting Coach of the Brewers for 2011?

Response
Votes
%
Yes
192
64%
No
56
19%
Undecided
51
17%

Should Brad Fischer return as Third Base Coach of the Brewers for 2011?

Response
Votes
%
Yes
50
17%
No
189
63%
Undecided
60
20%

Should Ed Sedar return as First Base Coach of the Brewers for 2011?

Response
Votes
%
Yes
214
72%
No
32
11%
Undecided
52
18%

Should Stan Kyles return as Bullpen Coach of the Brewers for 2011?

Response
Votes
%
Yes
165
55%
No
56
19%
Undecided
78
26%